评论
打印
Defenders of special protective labor legislation for women often maintain that eliminating such laws would destroy the fruits of a century-long struggle for the protection of women workers. Even a brief examination of the historic practice of courts and employers would show that the fruit of such laws has been bitter: they are , in practice, more of a curse than a blessing.
Sex-defined protective laws have often been based on stereotypical assumptions concerning women's needs and abilities, and employers have frequently used them as legal excuses for discriminating against women.After the Second World War, for example, businesses and government sought to persuade women to vacate jobs in factories, thus making room in the labor force for returning veterans. The revival or passage of state laws limiting the daily or weekly work hours of women conveniently accomplished this. Employers had only to declare that overtime hours were a necessary condition of employment or promotion in their factory, and women could be quite legally fired,refused jobs, or kept at low wage levels, all in the name of "protecting" their health. By validating such laws when they are challenged by lawsuits, the courts have colluded over the years in establishing different, less advant-ageous employment terms for women than for men, thus reducing women's competitiveness on the job market. At the same time, even the most well-intentioned lawmakers, courts, and employers have often been blind to the real needs of women. The law makers and the courts continue to permit employers to offer employee health insurance plans that cover all known human medical disabilities except those relating to pregnancy and childbirth.
Finally, labor laws protecting only special groups are often ineffective at protecting the workers who are actually in the workplace. Some chemicals, for example, pose repro-ductive risks for women of child-bearing years; manufacturers using the chemicals comply with laws protecting women against these hazards by refusing to hire them.Thus the sex-defined legislation protects the hypothetical female worker, but has no effect whatever on the safety of any actual employee.The health risks to male employees in such industries cannot be negligible,since chemicals toxic enough to cause birth defects in fetuses or sterility in women are presumably harmful to the human metabolism. Protective laws aimed at changing production materials or techniques in order to reduce such hazards would benefit all employees without discriminating against any.
In sum, protective labor laws for women are discriminatory and do not meet their intended purpose. Legislators should recognize that women are in thework force to stay, and that their needs-good health care, a decent wage,and a safe workplace-are the needs of all workers, Laws that ignore these facts violate women's rights for equal protection in employment.
According to the author, which of the following resulted from the passage or revival of state laws limiting the work hours of women workers?
A.Women workers were compelled to leave their jobs in factories.
B.Many employers had difficulty in providing jobs for returning veterans.
C.Many employers found it hard to attract women workers.
D.The health of most women factory workers improved.
E.Employment practices that addressed the real needs of women workers became common.
The author places the word “protecting” in quotation marks in line 21 most likely in order to suggest that
A.she is quoting the actual wording of the laws in question
B.the protective nature of the laws in question should not be overlooked
C.protecting the health of workers is important to those who support protective labor laws
D.the laws in question were really used to the detriment of women workers, despite being overtly protective in intent
E.the health of workers is not in need of protection, even in jobs where many hours of overtime work are required
The passage suggests that which of the following is a shortcoming of protective labor laws that single out a particular group of workers for protection?
A.Such laws are often too weak to be effective at protecting the group in question.
B.Such laws are usually drafted by legislators who, do not have the best interests of workers at heart.
C.Such laws exert no pressure on employers to eliminate hazards in the workplace.
D.Compliance with such laws is often costly for employers and provokes lawsuits by employees claiming discrimination.
E.Employer compliance with such laws results in increased tension among workers on the job, because such laws unfairly privilege one group of employees over another.
According to the first paragraph of the passage, the author considers which of the following to be most helpful in determining the value of special protective labor legislation for women?
A.A comparative study of patterns of work-related illnesses in states that had such laws and in states that did not
B.An estimate of how many women workers are in favor of such laws
C.An analysis of the cost to employers of complying with such laws
D.A consideration of what intentions the advocates of such laws really had concerning women workers
E.An examination of the actual effects that such laws have had in the past on women workers
The main point of the passage is that special protective labor laws for women workers are
A.unnecessary because most workers are well protected by existing labor laws
B.harmful to the economic interests of women workers while offering them little or no actual protection
C.not worth preserving even though they do represent a hard-won legacy of the labor movement
D.controversial because male workers receive less protection than they require
E.inadequate in that they often do not prevent employers from exposing women workers to many health hazards
The author implies that which of the following is characteristic of many employee health insurance plans?
A.They cover all the common medical conditions affecting men, but only some of those affecting women.
B.They lack the special provisions for women workers that proposed special labor laws for women would provide.
C.They pay the medical costs associated with pregnancy and childbirth only for the spouses of male employees, not for female employees.
D.They meet minimum legal requirements, but do not adequately safeguard the health of either male or female employees.
E.They have recently been improved as a result of the passage of new labor laws, but continue to exclude coverage of certain uncommon medical conditions affecting women.
According to the passage, special labor laws protecting women workers tend generally to have which of the following effects?
A.They tend to modify the stereotypes employees often hold concerning women.
B.They increase the advantage to employers of hiring men instead of women, making it less likely that women will be hired.
C.They decrease the likelihood that employers will offer more protection to women workers than that which is absolutely required by law.
D.They increase the tendency of employers to deny health insurance and disability plans to women workers.
E.They have little impact of any kind on women workers, since typically very few women are employed in those classes of jobs covered by the laws.
