if I knew you were going with Toby Cavanaugh?
You heard me.
Yes. You know what? You're right.
I wouldn't have. That guy is trouble.
People cross the street to the other side
when they see him coming.
I don't. I didn't...
I just thought he was misunderstood.
Different. You know what, I think his stepsister
probably thought he was different, too,
and now she needs a seeing-eye dog.
He didn't do that. It was an accident.
How do you know that, Emily?
And what about last night?
Was that an accident as well?
Come on, how many guys drop their dates off at the hospital
and then run away?
What's he trying to hide?
Honey, did he try to pressure you into something
you weren't ready for?
That's not what happened.
Well, then, what happened?
What happened, Emily?
Why don't you start by telling me that.
Toby Cavanaugh didn't get sent away for a year
because he rolled through a stop sign.
Do you have any ideas what our neighbors think of him,
what they're gonna think of you?
I need some sleep.