Do you remember anything else?
He cried when it was time to leave.
Said it was the best birthday he ever had.
The person they're describing on the news...
I mean, I don't even know who that is.
You played skeeball, once.
I wouldn't call that family bonding.
I think what Hanna's trying to say is that
it's hard for us to imagine that A is actually your brother.
No, what's hard to imagine is that you feel
even the slightest bit of pity for Charles.
Little harsh, Hanna--
He's been out for blood, for all of us!
And he's come way too close more than once.
We hear you, but it's unfair to Ali right now--
Why are you trying to shut me up, Spencer?
I'm just saying what you guys are thinking.
If you guys are too scared to be honest, then fine.
I will do it for you.
I'm sorry, Alison.
I know this must really suck for you.
But I'm not gonna sit here
and help you give A the benefit of the doubt.
I hope the police catch him because there's nothing
they could do to him that's worse than what he did to us.